14 Comments
User's avatar
Joshua Doležal's avatar

It's brave of you to write about this, Lyle. As someone in the early stages of this process now, I suppose I don't have enough distance to write about it publicly. And I do wrestle with the perennial question that memoirists face of how much of this kind of story is mine to tell. But you're right that there is nothing more clarifying than attending a wedding while feeling distant from a life partner. I suspect it has a catalyzing effect either way: toward repair or separation.

Expand full comment
Lyle McKeany's avatar

Thanks, Joshua! I agree that some distance is probably a good thing, for all involved.

Expand full comment
Sasha Levage's avatar

I'm glad I'm not the only one who cancelled all my other OKcupid dates after my first one on the site - did the same thing 11+ years ago. Still with the dang guy. We could be advertisements for OKCupid!

Thanks for sharing this life lesson, Lyle.

Expand full comment
Lyle McKeany's avatar

Lol, so funny! Thanks for always reading, Sasha.

Expand full comment
Ehud Neor's avatar

You've become what was missing for you during your break-up. A friend. Your writing is fine, but what you are doing with your life is finer still.

Expand full comment
Lyle McKeany's avatar

❤️

Expand full comment
Stanley's avatar

Thanks for sharing buddy. We’re you ever able to get closure with your first marriage? If it were me, not knowing what the root cause of the deterioration of the relationship would haunt me forever.

Expand full comment
Lyle McKeany's avatar

Ultimately, it was communication breakdown. I realize now that neither of us were truly hearing each other and listening with empathy when really mattered.

Expand full comment
Stanley's avatar

What do you think caused the communication breakdown thought? A couple doesn’t just stop listening and feeling for each other one morning, you know? (Also if this is too sensitive, I’ll go back to my Transformers)

Expand full comment
Lyle McKeany's avatar

I don't mind at all. You're right, it doesn't just suddenly stop. It's more like it accumulates over time. If you're bad at communication even when times are good it's just going to be exacerbated when things aren't going well. Defensiveness was the biggest issue for me personally. I often felt I was being attacked instead of actually listening and hearing her on an emotional level.

Expand full comment
Stanley's avatar

What do you think caused you to stop listing and hearing her and caused you to become so defensive and feeling attacked? Sounds like she could have been (at some level) emotionally abusive to have caused you to react to her like that

Expand full comment
Lyle McKeany's avatar

There was some aspect of that, for sure. I didn't write this to cast blame and I've since learned I played a larger role in the deterioration of our relationship than I first thought I did.

Defensiveness is super common, especially in men (I'm generalizing, I know). It could be with small things. I still do it from time to time, but I'm better at catching myself now.

Expand full comment
Ehud Neor's avatar

Lyle, looking at Stanly's line of questioning, let me ask you this: is there room for some kind of "communication skills" education in at least high school, if not earlier? Marriage prep so to speak. It's almost as if the first marriage is the trial-run marriage, destined to fail, and only if you are lucky you will gain the skills needed to make the next one work.

Expand full comment